Tonight's
Unveiled evening at
St Andrew's Wickford was on Jesus in popular songs. We listened to songs by Joan Osborne, Bob Dylan, Scott Stapp, Jackson Browne, Kendrick Lamar, and googly eyes, Joy Oladokun & Allison Ponthier:
Delvyn Case writes: 'From “Jesus, Take the Wheel” to “Jesus Walks” to “Dropkick Me, Jesus, Through the Goalposts of Life”, Jesus has appeared in hundreds of songs by popular musicians over the past 50 years. No longer just a subject for hymn writers and gospel composers, Jesus now shows up in secular music by rock stars, rappers, singer-songwriters, country stars, and hardcore punks. And that’s just for starters.
For over 50 years, pop musicians in all genres have explored the meaning and significance of Jesus in their music. The result is a rich collection of songs that consider important spiritual questions like faith, doubt, and prayer in unique and often provocative ways. This evening explores some of those songs and what they have to say about Jesus.'
‘What If God Was One of Us?’ by Joan Osborne“One of Us” is a song recorded by Joan Osborne released on November 21, 1995. It was written by Eric Bazilian (of the Hooters), produced by Rick Chertoff, and released as the lead single of Joan Osborne’s Relish album. It peaked at number four on the US Billboard Hot 100 and earned three Grammy nominations. It became a top-20 hit in at least twelve other countries. The song addresses various aspects of belief in God by asking a series of questions.
Several times during “One of Us,” the listener hears the haunting refrain “What if God was one of us?” The good news is that God was one of us. He came to be one of us. In Jesus, he became flesh, becoming human while remaining God.
Fred Herron writes, in a reflection on Osborne’s song: “Christians believe that God took on flesh and blood, or became human, in the person of Jesus. John’s gospel contains a fascinating verse, “So the Word [John adapting/applying Greek ideas of logos to Jesus] became human and made his home among us. He was full of unfailing love and faithfulness” (John 1:14; NLT).
I have always been fascinated with this idea that God disguised himself in human form. He shows up in unexpected ways—born in a manger, born in transient housing, born to a poor Jewish Palestinian woman under the suspicion of illegitimacy. Then Jesus, in his ministry, upends religious purity culture by showing up and practicing radical love towards the sick, the poor, the outsider, the sinner, the prisoner, the prostitute, and the wayward—those whom religious people avoided for fear of contamination. Jesus showed up in unexpected ways with “unfailing love,” teaching that we encounter God “in the least of these” (Matthew 25:40).”
This is what we see in Osborne’s song:
What if God was one of us?
Just a slob like one of us
Just a stranger on the bus
Tryin’ to make his way home?
‘Sweetheart Like You’ by Bob DylanIn ‘Sweetheart Like You’, from Bob Dylan’s 1983 album ‘Infidels’, we see a wonderfully contemporary depiction of Christ's incarnation. The song is written from the perspective of a misogynist male employee in an all-male workplace that is literally a hell of a place in which to work. To be in here requires the doing of some evil deed, having your own harem, playing till your lips bleed. There's only one step down from here and that's the ironically named 'land of permanent bliss.'
Into this perverted and prejudiced environment comes a woman, the sweetheart of the song's title. She is a Christ figure; a sinless figure entering into a world of sin and experiencing abuse and betrayal (is 'that first kiss' a Judas kiss?) from those she encounters and to whom she holds out the possibility of a different kind of existence. Dylan makes his equation of the woman with Christ explicit by quoting directly from Jesus: 'They say in your father's house, there's many mansions' (John 14: 2).
The song's narrator is confused and challenged by her appearance. He wants to dismiss her out of hand and back to his stereotypical role for her - 'You know, a woman like you should be at home / That's where you belong / Watching out for someone who loves you true / Who would never do you wrong' - but he can't simply dismiss her as she is really there in front of him and so he begins to wonder, 'What's a sweetheart like you doin' in a dump like this?' All the time he asks that question there is the possibility that he may respond to her presence without abuse or dismissal.
‘Jesus Was A Rock Star’ by Scott StappDavid Flowers writes that Scott Stapp “is best known for being founder and frontman of the rock band Creed”: “Creed’s lyrics in their albums My Own Prison (’97) and Human Clay (’99) were reflective of Stapp’s Christian upbringing, but he admits that he lived in rebellion against God for many years. He says he rebelled against a certain “brand” of Christianity that didn’t look much like Jesus. Religious fundamentalism drove him to the edge. Stapp became addicted to alcohol and prescription drugs, went through a divorce, and attempted suicide. It seemed he was on a course to join the 27 club. It was through the love and grace of his wife and mother-in-law that Stapp encountered a Christ that loves sinners. Scott Stapp repented of his sins and chose to walk the Jesus path.”
Stapp says of ‘Jesus Was A Rock Star’: “I think that song, again, has two different lines of thought with it. Number one, I'm not the rockstar, man. If you want to talk about who the rockstar is, it's Jesus. So, it's not about me, it's about Him. I wanted to just lay the case out there and be like, "Hey, let me tell you what a rockstar is." I just went right into it with laying the case for how that's who we should glorify. Not me. Then another line of thought in that song was that, [throughout] my whole life, I was told that the electric guitar was an instrument of the devil. And that, in being involved in rock'n'roll music, you couldn't be a Christian. You couldn't bring glory and honor to Christ and to God. So I had a conflict because of that spiritual abuse. I had a conflict that I really wrestled with my whole life because I had this hole in my soul that pulled me closer to God whenever I would play music-- and rock'n'roll music and electric guitar--but then I would feel this guilt and this shame and this condemnation because of how I was lied to and told that it was of the devil. I had this conflict, so I think in writing this song, too, it was to erase that conflict. That I CAN glorify Christ through a rock'n'roll song. I CAN be a Christian and a rock'n'roll singer. I CAN spread the message of Christ through rock'n'roll music. It was resolving that conflict within me. It was basically those two issues that inspired that song.”
‘The Rebel Jesus’ by Jackson BrowneSteve Stockman writes: “Rebel Jesus is a rarity in the Jackson Browne catalogue, hidden away on a The Chieftains' album ‘Bells Of Dublin’ and then as one of the … extra tracks on Browne's compilation album ‘The Next Voice You Hear’. It is however, as potent a Christmas song as you'll ever hear …
It indicts the dubious practices of those who claim to follow Jesus while seemingly contradicting his revolution. Browne uses the story of Christ over turning the tables in the temple to indict those who would abuse God’s Creation for selfish materialist wealth and throws in the “pride and gold” of Churches in the same verse!
In another verse the poor are ignored but might be thrown a token gesture in our Christmas generosity. The irony of the poor being ignored on Christmas Day when the baby celebrated was without a bed or food is the crux of the hypocrisy. How have we shut the door to the marginalised for a warm romanticised day of decadence is the question posed?
Browne then paraphrases Helder Camara’s quote, “If I feed the poor they call me a saint but if I ask why the poor are poor they call me a communist,” to powerful effect. If we decided to turn the world on its head by seeking social and economic justice for the oppressed we would get the same as The Rebel Jesus.”
‘How Much A Dollar Cost’ by Kendrick Lamarr“How much a dollar really cost?” This question is the focal point of Kendrick Lamar’s song of the same name (give or take a word), “How Much a Dollar Cost” from his third studio album, ‘To Pimp a Butterfly’.
Manny Adewale writes: “this song is based on a true story from Kendrick’s travels to South Africa during his time working on To Pimp a Butterfly, where he interacted with a homeless man after being reluctant to. In each verse, Kendrick narrates a different part of this story, exploring the thoughts and feelings that come with the pursuit of money, as well as cost of desiring to hang on to it …
Kendrick thinks that he’s seen through this man’s request for help; he sees this man as nothing more than a junkie or an alcoholic who’s pretending to be wise. Kendrick admits to his lack of empathy and his insensitivity towards this man. The homeless man then tells Kendrick, “Your potential is bittersweet.” Earlier, this man told Kendrick that he had the chance to be a leader and help those around him, but he now sees that Kendrick’s potential is bittersweet because he’s refusing to let go of his selfishness, stubbornness, and pride. Kendrick refuses to listen again, and as the instrumentation and the production swells, we reach the climax of the song, where the homeless beggar reveals his identity:
He looked at me and said, “Know the truth, it’ll set you free
You’re lookin’ at the Messiah, the son of Jehovah, the higher power
The choir that spoke the word, the Holy Spirit
The nerve of Nazareth, and I’ll tell you just how much a dollar cost
The price of having a spot in Heaven, embrace your loss — I am God”
This part of the song is personally my favorite because this is the moment where everything comes to a point, and Kendrick has an epiphany. Again, as a kid who grew up in a Christian home, I always learned that it was good to treat everyone with kindness because you’d never know if you’d just come across an angel:
“Don’t forget to show hospitality to strangers, for some who have done this have entertained angels without realizing it!” — Hebrews 13:2
I also learned about how Jesus said that showing kindness to those in need was to do so to Him:
“‘Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers of Mine, you did for Me.’” — Matthew 25:40
For me, this is always a reminder that our choice to be kind and generous to others is an important demonstration of what we believe, and it’s our chance to recognize God in every person we cross paths with.
The line “The price of having a spot in Heaven, embrace your loss” is also very striking here. In that same chapter where Jesus thanks those who took care of those in need and rewards them, he turns away those who didn’t. My siblings and I always learned that our generosity and kindness towards other people would be part of how God prepared us to experience the good things He has in store for us, especially Heaven itself.”
‘Jesus and John Wayne’ by googly eyes, Joy Oladokun and Allison PonthierA review at
Unheard Gems says: “Some songs arrive like lifelines—gently, honestly, and right when you need them. “Jesus and John Wayne” is one of those rare tracks. Born from the pages of Kristin Kobes Du Mez’s explosive book of the same name, the song unpacks the painful intersection of faith, identity, and politics with striking vulnerability and nuance. googly eyes, Joy Oladokun, and Allison Ponthier bring their voices together to create something that feels at once intimate and monumental …
This song is more than just a collaboration—it’s an act of reclamation. It redefines what faith can sound like: inclusive, expansive, and rooted in love rather than exclusion …. It’s not afraid to confront the damage done by institutional religion, but it also holds space for healing, for community, and for the radical belief that love—true love—belongs to everyone.
For anyone navigating the complex layers of queerness, spirituality, and self-worth, this track offers comfort without compromise. It’s a hymn for the misfits, the doubters, and the believers still learning to believe in themselves again.”
The song begins:
I liked the teachings of Jesus so much that I followed him right out the door
When steeples kept preaching with hate on their tongues
And distaste for the meek, mild and poor
and concludes with this critique of those who preach hate:
Blessed are the war makers
Blessed are the black in heart
Blessed are the politicians
Blessed are the patriarchs
Blessed are the gold takers
Blessed skin like porcelain
Blessed is America, but only for Americans
And if I had to admit
Jesus wouldn't really fit
With everything you're trying to do with him
Delvyn Case writes that, intended for their fans rather than worshipers, these songs often present Jesus in unique and unorthodox ways, many of which challenge the ways we traditionally think about him. Whether written by believers or atheists, all of these songs seek – in their own unique ways - to answer the oldest questions in Christianity: who was Jesus, what did he mean, and why is he important?
Delvyn has a website called
Rock of Ages which is a collection of songs about Jesus. He suggests that some songs treat Jesus exclusively as a human figure, shorn of any theological characteristics. Some depict him as a character in the narrative world of the song. In so doing they provide fascinating explorations of the distinctly human side of Jesus’s existence. These songs focus on Jesus as a Person.
In other songs, Jesus appears not as a human or a theological figure, but rather as a symbol - usually of an abstract idea or character trait. He is usually invoked as the ultimate signifier of whatever is being signified. Though the variety of attributes is quite broad, it is the view of Jesus as the ultimate symbol of power that is most common. These songs focus on Jesus as a Paragon.
His final category is Jesus as Presence in songs that reveal a complex or compelling engagement with the questions of Jesus’s meaning and/or significance.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Scott Stapp - Jesus Was A Rock Star.